Bibi’s Speech

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin (Bibi) Nrtanyahu gave a speech in Israel yesterday widely viewed as a response to President Obama’s Cairo speech. In it, Netanyahu conceded, for the first time, acceptance of the idea of a Palestinian state. He also provided an absolutely predictable and well worn set of conditions for proceeding toward the goal of two states that effectively guarantee that progress toward that goal will not occur.

Bibi’s continued (and, one assumes, heartfelt) reluctance to embrace a real Palestinian state is evident in the three conditions he places on progress toward the goal. First, he insists that the Palestinian state must be demilitarized and that there be international guarantees that Palestine will not develop a military capability. Second, he insists that the Palestinian state cede control over its air space, leaving that under the domain of the Israeli Air Force. Third, he insists that the Palestinians formally accept Israel as a Jewish state. The first two concerns arise from Israeli fears that a Palestinian state will become a sanctuary for attacks on Israel, with Hamas action in Gaza as thebasis for comparison. The third is to undermine any future argument the Palestinians might have for a return of Israeli territory to Palestinian control.

The speech was also notable for what it did not say. On the major point of contention between the U.S. and Israel, Bibi did not accept the principle of freezing and rolling back West Bank settlements. Instead, he agreed not to build new settlements but to allow the :natural growth” of those that exist. Second, he explicitly rejected the “right of return” of former Palestinian residents of Israel to go back to and reclaim territory they fled in 1948. Third, he reiterated his position that Jerusalem was the capital of Israel alone, thereby rejecting any claims the Palestinians had toward parts of the city and their claim that Jerusalem is also their capital.

Does the Netanyau speech break new ground or constitute any movement forward in the peace process to which the Obama administration appears committed? The answer is clearly that it does not. The speech was a rhetorical acceptance of the two-state principle, presumably to unruffle some feathers in Washington, but it continues to contain barriers to progress that guarantee that no progress is made. Was that the whole purpose of the speech? It certainly appears that way.


2 Responses to “Bibi’s Speech”

  1. William Bilek, M.D. Says:

    P.M. Netanyahu’s speech outlined widespread Israeli concensus that Israel must be able to provide for its own security; and that Israel is the (singular) nation-state of the Jewish people. To deny one, or the other, is to condemn the country, (and some believe, the Jewish people) to extermination. Why would anyone expect any country to be complicit in its suicide? The status of Jerusalem, and defensible borders are also mainstays of the opinions held by the majority of the Israeli electorate, which may, or may not, represent Israel’s initial negotiating positions.

    But it is interesting that while the Palestinians have never wavered or conceded a single iota regarding their demands for a Palestinian state on the 1967 armistice lines, with eastern Jerusalem as their capital and the right of millions of Palestinians to overwhelm Israel’s Jewish population; and while they continue to spew vile ant-Israeli and anti-Semitic calls to violence, and while they have never rescinded their “policy of stages”, and they have never disarmed their violent extremists, none of these are considered by the author of this blog as “barriers to progress.” There’s the rub!

  2. I found very informative. The article is professionally written and I feel like the author knows the subject very well. keep it that way.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: